Thursday, March 6, 2008

Too Much good News for the EURO? We'll see tomorrow! -IFCN Wk 13 -Thu- Equity: $637.77

Thank you, readers....

I've had 5 people email me about their results trading FirstStrike and OneNight Stand. All of them started on different weeks, but of course, they all had great results last week. I've printed part of one response below:

Hi Joel,

I'm not writing this because I have any pressing questions or intelligent remarks to make but rather to let you know I'm still here. I'm one of the readers of your forex newsletter and blog and I really appreciate all the work you're putting into those.


I started trading FS and ONS live week 2 of this year. I decided to use Oanda even though they lack OCO orders (and I've had some extra fills and stop outs because of this), mainly because they have no limit on minimum unit size.... As you wrote in your blog, when it rains it pours, and this (last) week has seen an 16.52% increase of the account. Nice after a 6 week drawdown.

But ... it's sooooooo easy to take your profits and run, especially after a drawdown.
Seeing the account being up so much, Thursday morning I tightened my stops and of course all of them got hit and I missed out on the Thursday and Friday run. Lesson learned. This (undesireable) behaviour has been reinforced a couple of times, because then it happened to be the right thing to do (equity wise, not system following wise).....

T-----


Thanks T-----, for the note. I'm glad you are having some success. Trading is much more challenging than most people give it credit.

Another great letter came today with very good questions. I'm including many of the details as well as my answers as they are probably things most readers of the blog will find interesting. My answers follow the questions in blue.  (private details always eliminated)

Hi Joel,

I am following your challenge with continued interest - has your related correspondence increased since the recent lift-off in your demo account equity?!


Yes, it has increased some. Most notable is how many new visitors the blog gets. It is very interesting from the perspective of “price being the greatest advertiser”.

Currently I'm reading 'Fooled by Randomness' (I'm finding it both fascinating and very entertaining) and have just bought Ralph Vince's latest work on Portfolio Management.

Good books! Vince is accurate, but you almost need a math major translator to help even if you were a math major. Taleb's works will forever stand the test of time. And they present the greatest possible benefit. The mind is the thing we need to tame the most.

I have coded First Strike for Trading Blox but so far have only tested it on EOD data. Where do you obtain your intraday FX data from? I've seen the free data from Dukascopy but am unsure how correct it is.

I use Signal. I don't need to test it (any longer), though. I trade it, and 5 versions similar to it (on different time frames). Amazingly, EOD data testing is just about as good as intraday testing (done correctly). It is a simple system. Simple things tend to work.

Do you exclusively use TradeStation for backtesting?

No. I also use custom software, and have used an Excel spreadsheet for testing.

Your point about systematic traders becoming more discretionary over time makes sense. For a beginner, having a rigid system as a framework is invaluable - as time goes on and you get more intuition/knowledge about the markets, then you can override your system in some ways. However I have read about experienced traders who have found these overrides have not really helped their performance.

I will go so far as to say that if you give someone a system that makes only 1 pip edge per trade after execution details-- mechanically-- and have an intelligent human trading it; within a relatively short time, perhaps a year or two-- he will likely be averaging 10 to 20 pips a trade using the same basic structure, with just a little personal input.

But only if he is really interested in making return. The most important part of a system is it's control over the human to force a loss or an exit of positions that are not going his way any longer. The second important thing is to force an entry that the human would not normally prefer to take.

In a thread on the Trading Blox forum you mention that an experienced trader can modify the size of a trade dependent on the level of edge it has. Do you think that your methods for this are objective enough to be added as additional rules/filters to a completely automated system?

Yes. But why make a completely automated system?

You wouldn't be able to trust it completely after you created it anyway. It would still be subject to more “handling”. Humans live in a “real” world which is changing perceptions every second. Only a properly trained human can get exceptional returns while machines can get very good returns.

That difference is why I can have a 240% return in a year, while my long term system from which I get the signals from makes only 62%. In a bad year my system will have a 45% drawdown, and I will experience a 35% drawdown. Taking the very same trades. Just different percentages of size in my entries and exits.  And knowing additional factors.

Luck? Sure. Maybe so.  I've been told that, “you're the luckiest bastard I've have ever known” for 25 years.

Luck is just a perception others have of someone doing something they don't think they can do. Anything I've done trading is possible for anyone (who doesn't drool) to learn. You just need to start trading a system that actually works a little..., and then continue learning. Knowing someone who has gone through the process (successfully) helps a lot too. I believe that I could show anyone with a 100 IQ and the ability to stop promptly at a stop sign--- how to trade profitably.

Finally, on the subject of slippage with Oanda. I'm currently testing with FXGame but am still not clear on the amount of slippage you get. Do you often get any slippage on your stop orders?

Less than one in 200 trades.

Good trading and thanks for making all this public.

Regards,

X-----


Thanks X---- for the input and the good questions. Best wishes.


To IFC Newsletter subscribers only:

As you know, a couple of days ago I sent out a trading alert about a low risk/high probability trade that I call the SURE-BREAKOUT TRADE. The details below went with it:

“This shorter term trade is a very powerful one that I've traded for many years. It is one of the strongest stand alone methods I've seen. It requires waiting for a market to achieve a balanced state and then one takes a breakout trade from a particularly tight, mathematically defined (price and time) range. It has a profit target listed which can be used to drop the entire position, or in the case of the trade being in the direction of the overall trend..., a place to drop off perhaps half of your position and make it possible for you to have a better than "free" trade in the direction of the trend.

The odds on this trade are very good. It typically wins 70% of the trades to the profit target. Losses are always about 2/3rds the size of the profit target. If one breakout fails, meaning I get stopped out before hitting the profit target, I always am willing to take the reverse trade if it happens within 12 hours of the stopout loss. Otherwise, the first trade is the trade I take on this setup.”

Then I sent out a recap after it executed:

The SURE-BREAKOUT TRADE sent out yesterday was a success!

Gbp/Usd:

SELL 1.9812, stop 1.9878. Profit Target= 1.9732

The trade was executed @ 1:10 CST and was completed at 3:05 CST.
Profit: 80 pips
--------------------
I took the trade in the Alpha account too. There were 4 others this week that happened in other pairs that I didn't take in the challenge account. I may end up making a separate (free) blog for just Sure Breakout trades that I notice setup. I will let you know if it happens. Time is precious for me. I like to sleep too.

Alpha account equity now at $637.77.

This has been a choppy week in most of the currency pairs.

Tomorrow should be a key day in these currencies with the first Friday release of Employment figures.

See you tomorrow.

Thanks for watching.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com
leonardo@infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to: newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me to which address you would like it sent.

PPS: Please do not use AOL or Yahoo addresses. Nothing personal, but they've been known to filter out more good mail than actual spam. Try a Gmail address. It's free, simple and perfect for traders!


Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Europe has No Problems! -IFCN Wk 13 -Tue- Equity: $627.48

We had some serious down action in gold and silver today, along with many grain markets. When tons of funds and latecomers get into markets that have been hot for months, the days come when someone starts selling and more selling seems inevitable for a while.

It is good to consider a few things about last week's action. Over the number of months the Eur/Usd attempted to approach the psychological 1.5000 zone. Finally, it was crossed last week on news: bad economic news from the US and amazing good news from the European community.

Even though they are experiencing similar disadvantages like negative exchange rates influencing foreign buying, very high energy cost, and taxation up the wazoo-- they're supposedly doing just great. I personally don't believe it, but hey- the Europeans wouldn't lie about it, would they?

The Non-Farm payroll info is out Friday. Maybe we'll see a market move that gives us a better indication of which financial group is telling more truth. What is great about large reports like this is the fact that all the major players are forced to play “a” hand. Maybe not at full strength, but there is always some risk to all players, even well capitalized ones.

Until tomorrow.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to:
newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me to which address you would like it sent.

PPS: Please do not use AOL or Yahoo addresses. Nothing personal, but they've been known to filter out more good mail than actual spam. Try a Gmail address. It's free, simple and perfect for traders! Huge storage too.


Monday, March 3, 2008

One Night Stand works as billed! -IFCN Wk 13 -Mon- Equity: $627.48

After the high flying week last week, the weekend served to push our OneNightStand trades even further. Which is the idea behind the robust trade concept.

By our exit time on Monday morning @ 00:00 CST/ 01:00 EST/ 06:00 GMT, we achieved the following results:

OneNightStand 02/29/08 entries held over the weekend:

gbp/jpy: Sold @ 207.94, exit @ 204.61 for 333 pips profit
usd/chf: Sold @ 1.0484, exit @ 1.0339 for 145 pips profit
usd/jpy: Sold @ 104.57, exit @ 103.08 for 149 pips profit

After exiting our OneNightStand trades, our equity stood at $658.09.

Then my FirstStrike orders were placed.

Within a very short time I was positioned as follows, and promptly stopped out:
  • Eur/Usd: Short @ 1.5162, stopped out for 60 pip loss
  • Gbp/Jpy: Short @ 204.25, stopped out for 70 pip loss (10 pip error in order entry- See, I make errors too!)
  • Gbp/Usd: Short @ 1.9808, stopped out for 60 pip loss
  • Usd/Chf: Long @ 1.0392, stopped out for 60 pip loss
  • Usd/Jpy: Short @ 102.66, stopped out for 60 pip loss
After exiting our OneNightStand trades, our equity stood at $627.48.

So there is the week already. It will be interesting if the trend from last week continues much further. It was truly spectacular. Perhaps it will take a breather this week. As you can see by watching the market action after getting stopped out of the first FirstStrike trades, if one took the reverse trades the results would have been less than spectacular.

This is probably a good week to stand on the sidelines.

Have a good evening.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to: newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me to which address you would like it sent.

PPS: Please do not use AOL or Yahoo addresses. Nothing personal, but they've been known to filter out more good mail than actual spam. Try a Gmail address. It's free, simple and perfect for traders! Huge storage too.


Friday, February 29, 2008

Dollar melt down! All New Total Equity Peak--IFCN Wk 12 -Fri- Equity: $623.28

We have reached a key point this week. We have survived our first major drawdown and succeeded in attaining new equity highs!

What you find out the longer you trade is the single solitary fact-- you spend the majority of your time with substantially less wealth than you've had in the past. Drawdowns occupy more than 95% of your trading life.

Get used to it. I did, but I still don't like drawdowns.

So, weeks like this are some of the few times that you really feel validated. Charging to a new equity high (in just one big week) after a 16% drawdown (from $580.41) helps you get the feel of what high reward trading is all about.

FirstStrike Trading theory:
Drawdowns take place due to insufficient trends, so FirstStrike's small fixed losses do their jobs. As equity drops, so does the capital risk for each trading pair. Your drawdowns tend to slow to less than a linear rate. When the statistical trends re-emerge, you gain back the temporarily lost equity-- exponentially.

We have achieved a 24.6% total increase in the last 12 complete weeks of the Alpha account for the Ultimate Forex Challenge! That is an effective 105% annual return.

It will be very unlikely that we will continue at this pace for long. The odds are in our favor though,  that we'll hit our 50+% return goal later in the year.

I'll keep putting in the trades.  And, I'm glad to have you watching the progress.

If anyone put on trades similar to these this week, feel free to drop me a note. I'd be interested to hear how they worked out, and if you use a different platform than Oanda.

I got an email from a reader this morning after sending out the ONS orders:

Joel,

All my entries were like yours except the GBP/JPY. The 10 was over 40 so I set up a buy stop and not a sell stop. I am assuming you looked at the angle of the 10 and thought better to short? Or was it the news out of Japan last night? Thanks

C-----


My answer:

On my charting package, the 10 was under the 40 on the GBP/JPY. Hence the trade signal.

Breakouts, all by themselves; have an edge. Some breakouts edges are bigger than others, of course.

In the simple system of ONS, the moving averages just filter out some less favorable (read: lower probability) breakouts. So, a trader could figure: Since it is a close call, with the angle of the averages and how close the breakout is... etc., and decide to take it. I personally wouldn't have a problem with that, since the stoploss takes care of the risk. Maybe take that kind of trade with 1/2 size.

But in this case, my charting package showed the 10 day average just barely under the 40. So that made it a short.

Thanks C------


This week we had some good OneNightStand trades.  Just one loss, the Eur/Usd.

This week's Alpha account trading recap:
Start of week equity: $486.25

Completed FirstStrike trades:
  • Eur/Usd:  Long @ 1.4867, exited @ 1.5176 for 309 pip profit
  • Gbp/Jpy:  Short @ 210.64, exited @ 211.24 for 60 pip loss
  • Gbp/Usd: Long @ 1.9709, exited @ 1.9856 for 147 pip profit
  • Usd/Chf:   Short @ 1.0836, exited @ 1.0418 for 418 pip profit
  • Usd/Jpy:   Long @ 107.91, exited @ 107.67 for 24 pip loss
Total of    84 pips in losses.
Total of 874 pips in profits.
-----
OneNightStand Exit(s) on 02/25/07:
Exited short Usd/Chf @ 10873 for 8 pip loss.
OneNightStand 02/29/08 entries:
  • eur/usd: Long @ 1.5231, stopped out @ 1.5176 for a 55 pip loss
  • gbp/jpy: Sold @ 207.94, unrealized profit of 147 pips
  • usd/chf: Sold @ 1.0484, unrealized profit of 77 pips
  • usd/jpy: Sold @ 104.57, unrealized profit of 73 pips
-----
Unrealized P&L:           $ 31.15
End of week equity:  $ 623.28 (includes unrealized P&L)
Total Gain on Week: $ 136.78 (28.1% weekly increase)

See you Monday!

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to:
newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me to which address you would like it sent.

PPS: Please do not use AOL or Yahoo addresses. Nothing personal, but they've been known to filter out more good mail than actual spam.
Try a Gmail address. It's free, simple and perfect for traders! HUGE email storage too.


Thursday, February 28, 2008

Alpha account is up 22 percent-- --IFCN Wk 12 -Thu- Equity: $593.66


What great action this week!

The account is sitting at $593.66 current equity, including unrealized profits!

This is what the currency markets look like when they want to go somewhere. If the Usd/Jpy short had been entered, we would have had another 250 pips.

FirstStrike trade status this week:

  • Gbp/Jpy: Short @ 210.64, stopped out @ 211.24 for a 60 pip loss.
  • Usd/Jpy: Long @ 107.91, exited @ 107.67 for 24 pip loss
  • Eur/Usd: Long @ 1.4867, stop 1.4807. Currently 300+ pips
  • Gbp/Usd: Long @ 1.9709, stop 1.9649. Currently 150+ pips
  • Usd/Chf: Short @ 1.0836, stop 1.0896. Currently 300+ pips

Also, it looks like a number of OneNightStand trades might get triggered on Friday.

When it rains, it pours.

See you tomorrow. Have a good night.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to: newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me to which address you would like it sent.

PPS: Please do not use AOL or Yahoo addresses. Nothing personal, but they've been known to filter out more good mail than actual spam. Try a Gmail address. It's free, simple and perfect for traders! Huge storage too.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Quick! Adapt or Perish!--IFCN Wk 12 -Wed- Equity: $563.78

The Alpha account had a very good day.

It is currently at $563.78-- up more than $75 from last Friday.  We are still long Eur/Usd and Gbp/Usd, and short Usd/Chf with substantial open profits.

This week's volatility, in the currencies and other important markets highlights the question of why do traders do what they do?

Almost all people trying to trade apparently do it to make gains or money on their capital. How traders accomplish that task is where they all differ.

Most know that traders make profits utilizing many different techniques. Timeframe and risk tolerance filters out which basic style a trader will primarily inhabit.

There are two primary successful groups who trade; the totally mechanical traders (or at least those who wish to be as mechanical as possible) and those who trade low risk setups and have a more "fluid" approach to trading the markets. Both only succeed if they have an definable edge.

The benefit of the first group's style is that entries and exits are well-planned and usually very executable by design. The benefit of the latter group's style is they can find numerous opportunities that are situational in nature and can take advantage of them with little prep time. A significant number of the second group occasionally get stunning trades, which seems to validate their style for those who favor it. Often the people who trade this way have a personal nature that makes it difficult for them to follow a strict approach.

I have observed that members of the mechanical group tend to regard the "fluid" types either as anomalies or unexplainable exceptions and consider them an annoyance similar to a webpage pop-up.

I find both styles have tremendous merit.

What most newer traders don't realize is--- the longer one trades, whichever of the groups you start in--- as you get more successful you will gravitate towards the other group and adopt more of the other's style.

I had a very busy day today, answering the phone every few minutes between trades. Watching 20 markets for potential orders and following up on fills that get held up is enough by itself most days.

I talked to 9 different traders (most of them commodity fund managers) about the "crazy" volatility we are experiencing.

Lenin once said that Wheat was the ultimate currency. What we've seen the last few weeks in Minneapolis and Chicago lends credence to his words.

Today, Chicago Wheat went from up 60 cents to limit down-- down $1.35 from the previous close ($6,750 contract) to limit up-- $2.70 higher ($13,500/contract) within an hour. Wheat actually jumped the last $2.10 ($10,500/contract) of the move in less than 3 minutes.

Minneapolis Wheat for March dropped $5.40/bushel right after the open. From the high put in Monday at $25.00/bushel the market's low today at $17.00 meant that it had a 32% drop in 2 days. That is $40,000 per contract loss in 44 hours. I know a guy who had 30 contracts through the last 2 days. He isn't happy.

In every case, the primarily-mechanical-trading professionals I talked to had to trade differently than their models typically require.

To make the necessary deviations each of them had to go back to their personal belief system drawing-boards and determine what it was they were ultimately trying to accomplish when they started--- and if that concept still applies. If it does, are they accomplishing their mission the best way possible by following their current method? Maybe all they need is a contingency plan for high volatility. Or maybe their system was never really "right".

When faced with simultaneous, completely unbelieveable action in wheat, some of the metals, petroleum products and currencies-- many systems were not up to the challenge.  Systems break down when liquidity fails.  

Systems, whether mechanical or subjective, are products of the markets themselves. When the markets turn into something that is unrecognizable by the human who is attempting to extract gain, the core beliefs of the trader are tested in a way that no simulator could ever conceive.

Truth is stranger than fiction. This mandate applies to markets also.

What are your core beliefs? Can they, and your current systems handle crazed markets?  Currency markets can also get extreme.  Do you have a contingency plan for that time?
 
Stay sane. I'll attempt to do the same.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to: newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me which address you would like it sent.


Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Dollar hits an air pocket! IFCN Wk 12 -Tue- Equity: $536.24


Looks like a good week for FirstStrike so far. It took a while for the market pairs to pick a direction, but when they did-- we've gotten some line moves.

A recap of our entries today:

Usd/Jpy: Went long yesterday @ 107.91, exited today @ 107.67 for 24 pip loss. I simply got out early. The market failed at an area it should have held if it was going to go higher.

I saw no reason to take a bigger loss just to prove a point. Also, the Euro, Swiss and Pound all were gaining strongly on the dollar. Under these circumstances there was no reason to wait for the inevitable loss.
  • Eur/Usd:  Long @ 1.4867, stop 1.4807.
  • Gbp/Usd: Long @ 1.9709, stop 1.9649.
  • Usd/Chf:   Short @ 1.0836, stop 1.0896.
Any trade above not stopped out before Friday-- exit on Friday just before 15:00 CST.

It is always surprising how quick one can rebound from a drawdown. The week isn't over yet, but at least we're seeing positive action.

See you tomorrow.

Joel Rensink
www.infiniteyield.com

PS: To receive the FREE! trading rules for the Infiniteyield Forex Challenge ($499 value) and the semi-monthly newsletter about this challenge, send an email to: newsletter@infiniteyield.com and tell me which address you would like it sent.